|
Literary critics
of Henry James novella The Turn of the Screw have
tended to take one of three interpretive positions regarding
the role of the young governess who comes to a mansion to care
for two young children, and there becomes convinced that the
ghosts of the former valet and governess are attempting to morally
corrupt the young ones. The first interpretation, often referred
to in James criticism as the first story, states
that the young governess is defending the children from the
evil embodied by the ghosts of Peter Quint and Miss Jessel.
The second interpretation takes the opposite position, which
states that the governess is imagining the ghosts, and is herself
the greatest danger the children face. The third view is that
James purposefully makes the story ambiguous by not allowing
the reader to decide between the first or second views. Benjamin
Brittens opera, The Turn of the Screw, makes a
case for the third interpretation by using musical themes that
at times seem to support the governess innocence, and
at other times, to imply her guilt. The listener is left in
the same uncertain position as Brittens governess, and
is not allowed to easily decide who is good or evil. Unlike
the governess, who cannot bear the uncertainty of not knowing
whether she is innocent or guilty, and who tends to leap to
explanations blaming the ghosts or herself, the listener is
challenged by an opera which does not allow for such solutions.
|
|